There are many reasons to hate American Idol: the constant commercial breaks, Ryan Seacrest’s stupid midget face, Paula Abdul’s incoherent babbling, awkward dancing, and plastic face, Simon Cowell’s contrived cynicism, the fact that everything the judges, contestants, and audiences do seems contrived, the lack of the word “contrived”… I could go on. But for a few weeks it was exactly those reasons that I loved watching American Idol. It was stupid, it was fun, it was easy fodder for jokes and photoshops.
But this week’s episode was different for me. It wasn’t different in any of the ways I mentioned above. It just felt different to me. Sure there were plenty of moronic things said (“Yo Dawg, you are one of the best singers in this competition” may seem like a compliment, but not when you say it to every contestant, and there are only 7 of them), plenty of awkward incoherent babbling (Paula’s remark about Kris “shopping in the women’s department”, and Simon’s reaction) and plenty of Seacrest’s stupid midget face. What was different wasn’t anything missing, but my realization that some (read: a lot of) people actually take this seriously and actually think that what they are seeing is good music.
I realize that taste is a personal preference and I may seem condescending saying this but none of the performers on American Idol that I have seen (with the glaring exception of Adam Lambert) have ever given what I would consider a great musical performance. I’m not saying it’s not music, or that it’s not entertaining, it’s just not good music. There is one contestant in particular that I feel embodies this as well as the antithesis of the way I feel about music: Danny Gokey.
I hate Danny Gokey. The fact that he is pretty much the favorite to win the competition legitimately makes me angry. The fact that the judges, even Simon occasionally, praise him on nearly every performance makes me furious. The fact that Paula Abdul may sincerely believe that he has “one of sexiest voices ever” makes me want to punch Paula Abdul in the face. Danny Gokey doesn’t have a sexy voice, he has a technically sound singing voice, but his voice doesn’t have any personality, he doesn’t have any personality, unless you count the “I’m white and wear glasses, so I’m dorky and non-threatening” smile he constantly has as personality (which I don’t).
One of the judges said in this week’s episode was “worried about [Gokey] and disco” as if they don’t fit together. On the contrary, disco is a perfect fit for Danny Gokey because they both display a complete and utter contempt for the notion that music is a legitimate art form. He goes out there every week, with his shit-eating grin and gives the most technically sound, cornball performance he can give and somehow America eats it up. There are other contestants that are nearly the same (Anoop and Matt), but they actually have some attributes (Anoop is Indian, Matt pretends to be Justin Timberlake) that give them some semblance of personality or charm, but Gokey is a complete void where no original thought or charm can be found. I would say he is a black hole, but black holes suck everything in, whereas Gokey seems to actively repel anything that would make him distinguishable as a human being.
I’m not sure why it bothers me this much. Given the history of American Idol the past few years, these are the types of people that usually end up winning or doing well. I know that the American public is dumb, but I think that seeing it this way just kind of rubs it in to me that the general public has completely different taste in music than me. I prefer music that actually says something (and not “She Works Hard For The Money”, which says “always tip your prostitute”), apparently a lot of AI viewers want music that completely lacks feeling and personality. I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree.
There is one saving grace of American Idol though, and his name is Adam Lambert. He is clearly the only one of the contestants who is truly gifted artist. He has a personality, and it shows through his performances. The fact that he and Gokey are most likely going to be the final two is exciting in a way. It can be framed as some sort of musical holy war between good and evil music. If Lambert wins, my musical tastes will be validated by the public (I can’t decide if I want this or not). If Gokey wins, I can go on hating mainstream pop music with good reason.